Liverpool People’s History

Revisiting the 1970s and 1980s

Rehousing Liverpool (4): Militant and ‘bourgeois’ housing

0 comments

For several years in the 1980s Liverpool city council was dominated by members of Labour’s Militant Tendency which promised to build a thousand new council homes every year. Elsewhere in the country, municipal housebuilding was almost at a standstill and the cost of Liverpool’s ambitious plans brought a confrontation with the Thatcher government.
Militant also had ideological objections to housing co-ops which it saw as a backdoor form of privatisation benefiting the bourgeoisie rather than the working class.
This is the fourth in a series of four articles on housing by Matt Thompson:

.

  1. From slum clearance to rehabilitation
  2. Grassroots initiatives
  3. Liberal compromises
  4. Militant and ‘bourgeois’ housing

.

"Hatton houses" from the Militant period, overlooked by the cathedral tower

“Hatton houses” from the Militant period, overlooked by the cathedral tower

.
In the local elections of 1983 popular concern about the state of Liverpool’s council housing helped Labour to secure victory. At the time, the council’s Labour group was controlled by the Militant Tendency, a far-left entryist group within the national party. Only nine of the 51 Labour councillors elected that year actually supported Militant, but they exercised extraordinary power over the council’s policies for the next five years.

Labour had gone into the local election promising not to cut jobs or increase rates (the predecessor of council tax) – which proved very popular among voters. Militant’s appeal, in the words of Peter Kilfoyle, one of its Labour opponents, was that it offered a “clear and simple analysis of the political condition, together with soundbite solutions, which struck a chord with the young, the idealistic and the naïve”.

Following the election, the council sought to end a decade of under-investment by announcing a budget with a £30 million deficit. Central government contributions to Liverpool council’s budget had fallen from 62% in 1980 to just 44% in 1983 due to a recalculation of the block grant based upon previous expenditure, which had been lower in Liverpool than in comparable cities. Labour blamed this on the Liberals, accusing them of having run down the budget and set the rates intentionally low in order to attract potential Liberal voters.

To implement Labour’s ambitious programme of municipal socialism, the council would either have to raise the rates by 170% or run a deficit, which would bring confrontation with the government – and it chose the latter course.

Ambitious plans

A central policy of the new Militant-led council was the Urban Regeneration Strategy (URS) which included a £350 million programme of council house building, centred on seventeen “Priority Areas”, with a target of building a thousand new homes every year until 1988. This was a remarkable figure for a time when, nationally, municipal housebuilding had all but come to a standstill.

The new homes would replace more than 5,000 dwellings in dilapidated tenements and tower blocks, and a further 15,000 existing council houses would be upgraded. The plan also included provision of new leisure centres, schools, parks and other public infrastructures and environmental improvements.

The URS was undeniably popular among Liverpool’s large council tenant population but it was bad news for the city’s growing co-op housing movement. Rightly or wrongly, Militant associated co-ops with the privatisation of public housing. It accused the Liberals of diverting public funds into a privatised sector of housing which was incapable of addressing the structural issues facing the city. In contrast to the huge scale of the problem – with more than 10,000 people on waiting lists to be housed – the tiny capacity of the marginal co-op movement was inadequate to meet the challenge.

Opposition to co-ops

Militant’s deeply held ideological opposition to co-ops – as an elitist, exclusionary and nepotistic form of housing – was grounded in experience. Co-ops were not open to new members on the basis of need alone and so in this respect fell far short of the socialist ideal of universality. The pre-allocations process, requiring that residents be selected before design or construction began, was a fundamental part of co-ops’ development, ensuring that residents were centrally involved in the process of creating their own homes – an intrinsic part of dweller control.

However, this also gave legitimacy to the lever by which close-knit communities ensured only their own kind – those sharing similar ethnic, religious and cultural identities – would be included. Self-selection was visible in the adjoining but sharply divided Mill Street and Shorefields co-ops, exclusively catering for Catholic and Protestant residents respectively. There was also a co-op called ‘Friends and Neighbours’ that literally consisted of friends and neighbours.

Despite the fact that all co-op members were sourced from poor working class communities, with many in severe housing need, the co-ops were, if not elitist, then certainly exclusionary.

Whilst Militant had a point about the shortcomings of co-op housing, their reaction against the movement was not commensurate with the threat posed to socialist values. Rather than see co-ops as the natural ally of socialism – or simply a compatible and complementary sector of public housing, catering to a minority desiring more dweller control and choice – Militant conflated co-ops with the Liberals’ ‘bourgeois’ approach to housing policy.

The main architect of URS was Tony Byrne, who later became chair of the council’s powerful Housing and Finance committees. Though avowedly ‘non-Militant’, he was a committed socialist and told one newspaper: “I believe in public ownership, control and accountability for housing through the elected council. It is the local authority who must satisfy the needs of the working class.”

In Byrne’s view, decision-making about housing should be centralised and in the hands of the council, since it was elected by the people, working for the people and making decisions in the interests of the people (but all too often without their further input or participation). This placed him in opposition to all forms of decentralised public provision through housing associations; an ideology that rested on a concomitant suspicion of community control as just another form of petit bourgeois privatism.

For Byrne, the answer was large-scale municipal housebuilding, which would provide jobs and decent homes for all and improve the urban environment in the process; and yet this came with rather rigid ideas about the type of housing to be provided. In promoting municipal housing as a panacea for urban ills Byrne became seduced by a form of design determinism.

The aim was to replace modernist ‘hard-to-let’ flats and tenements built between the 1930s and 1970s. These had become unpopular sites marked by crime, vandalism, squalor and dereliction and Byrne’s assessment of council house designs revealed one promising inter-war period of problem-free semi-detached housing. He concluded that this was the pinnacle of British council housing design.

‘Defensible’ space

At around the same time, academic geographer Alice Coleman was popularising her ideas on the ‘design disadvantagement’ of modernist council estates. In her provocatively named book, Utopia on Trial, she recommended that ‘corrective measures’ should modify the worst features of existing council blocks; that no further council flats should be built; and that in their place should be semi-detached houses with front and back gardens, bounded territorially by walls or fences.

Coleman’s work drew on the “defensible space” theory developed in the US by city planner Oscar Newman. The basic idea was to design housing projects in ways that would “allow inhabitants themselves to become key agents in ensuring their security” – thus avoiding many of the problems that afflicted high-rise blocks.

Ironically, this not only appealed to Byrne and Militant but also to the Liverpool co-ops and the Thatcher government: it informed the “Right to Buy” policy and the general trend towards the privatisation of council estates and the ‘responsibilisation’ of tenants. The co-ops, meanwhile, had included some defensible space principles in their designs, especially in the creation of “wagon circle” cul-de-sacs, overlooked gardens and external boundary fencing.

The “defensible space” theory in action: sketches by architect Rob MacDonald showing the use of “wagon circle” housing grouped around cul-de-sacs in various examples of new-build co-ops on Merseyside.

Byrne was adamant that Coleman was on to something and invited her to Liverpool for a site visit. In a strange twist, Coleman gave her seal of approval to Militant housing policy, proclaiming in an interview with the Daily Post that “Liverpool has got it right”. Leading Militant members were proud to report that “she completely concurred with the main thrust of the URS and of the council’s conviction that the majority of people preferred to live in traditional houses”.

The Coleman/Byrne design approach worked on the assumption that people wanted semi-detached houses arranged along streets with through-flow, overlooking the fact that in the co-op participatory design process residents had opted for terraces, enclosed courtyards, cul-de-sacs and communal features. In many ways, the URS made the same mistake as the post-war modernist council designs it critiqued: a top-down focus on form over function, on housing type over any consideration of tenant participation in its design, management or ownership. The URS replaced many alienating high-rise flats and council estates with more-popular, human-scale traditional houses, but the rigid, distant paternalistic management structure remained unmoved.

Militant believed they were giving people what they truly wanted; and in many respects they had accurately captured the mood of many tenants, alienated by dysfunctional and decaying council flats.

Owing to constraints imposed by the ongoing budget battle, however, the new housing was often of a lower design quality than the council housing it replaced and often not big enough for tenants to fit in the furniture from their previous homes. Little wonder, then, that local Labour politician Peter Kilfoyle – albeit a vociferous critic of Militant – described them as “stupid little doll’s houses”. More recent critiques have been no less scathing. In his architectural dérive of Liverpool, Owen Hatherley points to the incongruous effect of planting suburban-style homes in the inner city:

“It’s not dignified for the city centre to mimic the ’burbs. It leads to depressing juxtapositions [with larger and often more impressive buildings] … the scale is preposterous, with the houses seeming to desperately want to be somewhere less dramatic.”

Thwarted ambitions

Militant had come to power with a promise to permit co-ops so long as they did not divert resources from the URS. In practice, however, Militant pursued an aggressive campaign against co-ops, even to the extent of moving URS Priority Area boundaries to include a block of flats they had initially agreed to transfer to local residents to renovate as a co-op, so as to build new council houses instead.

Shortly after the election, the council decided to place a moratorium on all further funding of co-ops and to take into municipal control those already started. Through its legal powers, the council was able to take full control of eight co-ops but this brought them into conflict with the URS guidelines requiring all new developments to fit the standardised through-road semi-detached housing layouts, foreclosing all possibility of cooperative designs that incorporated communal spaces or courtyards. The loss of central communal play spaces, gardens and community centres – the heart of cooperative housing – was particularly problematic for the successful functioning of co-ops unlucky enough to be caught up in municipalisation.

Except in rare cases of resistance, the Militants brought the cooperative movement to a standstill in Liverpool at a time when it was receiving unprecedented policy support nationally.

* * *

Matt Thompson is Lecturer in Urban Studies at the Bartlett School of Planning, University College London. This article is an edited extract from his book, Reconstructing Public Housing: Liverpool’s Hidden History of Collective Alternatives, published by Liverpool University Press in 2020.

FURTHER INFORMATION

POLITICAL TOPICS:

Militant Liverpool: A City on the Edge
Diane Frost and Peter North. Liverpool University Press, 2013.

Liverpool: A City that Dared to Fight
Peter Taafe and Tony Mulhearn. Fortress Books, 1988.

Inside Left: The Story So Far
Derek Hatton. Bloomsbury, 1988.

Left Behind: Winning Back a Labour Heartland and the Defeat of Militant
Peter Kilfoyle. Politico’s Publishing, 2000.

Liverpool on the Brink: One City’s Struggle Against Government Cuts
Michael Parkinson.

Labour: A Tale of Two Parties
Hilary Wainwright. Hogarth Press, 1987.

HOUSING TOPICS:

Defensible Space on the Move: Revisiting the Urban Geography of Alice Coleman
Jane Jacobs and Loretta Lees. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37, no. 5 (27 September 2013)

Citizenship and Consumption in the Development of Social Rights: The Liverpool New-Build Housing Co-operative Movement
Paul Lusk. Unpublished thesis, Salford University, 1998.

The Rebirth of Liverpool: The Eldonian Way
Jack McBane. Liverpool University Press, 2008.

Housing Vacancy and the Shrinking City: Trends and Policies in the UK and the City of Liverpool
Chris Couch and Matthew Cocks. Housing Studies 28, no. 3 (2013)

Contesting ‘dilapidated dwelling’
Matthew Thompson. Chapter in From Conflict to Inclusion in Housing

 

 

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST POSTS

Friends of the Earth and the war against waste

In the 1970s, amid an ever-growing volume of rubbish dumped into landfill sites, environmental activists began a campaign to promote recycling.

Something nasty in the air: residents’ battles against noxious chemicals

Accidental emissions and hazardous waste from Merseyside’s chemical industries caused much alarm in the early 1970s. The government responded with two important pieces of legislation: the Control of Pollution Act and the Health & Safety at Work Act.

From riots to regeneration: Michael Heseltine and the great Mersey clean-up

How the Thatcher government’s environment minister inspired a campaign against pollution – and laid the foundations for Liverpool’s economic revival.

George Melly

George Melly was a multi-talented musician, writer and entertainer – a larger-than-life character noted for his exuberant sartorial style.

How working on ‘the Lump’ angered trade unions and caused a taxing problem for the government

The ‘Lump’ was a controversial practice in the construction industry where workers received a lump sum for each completed job, instead of a weekly wage. ‘Lump’ workers could earn more than regular employees but since they were supposedly self-employed they had no job security and were not covered by health and safety regulations.

Bob Dylan in Liverpool: 1966 and all that

When pop music came of age Liverpool was at its heart. Not only the Beatles and Merseybeat. Bob Dylan was part of it too. PHIL OATES explores the singer-poet’s connections with the city and how, on the sidelines of a controversial concert in 1966, it became a place of pilgrimage where he paid tribute to some of his literary and musical heroes.

How male prejudice toppled Britain’s highest-ranking police woman

In 1983 Alison Halford achieved what no woman had done before: she became an Assistant Chief Constable in Merseyside police – which also made her the highest-ranking officer anywhere in Britain. Nine years later, though, her police career lay in ruins. In an acrimonious legal battle she accused the police of sex discrimination and the police retaliated by accusing her of misconduct.

Mathew Street and the ‘Pool of Life’

The Beatles were gone but in the 1970s Mathew Street lived on as the epicentre of Liverpool creativity, drawing its energy from Eric’s Club, the Liverpool School of Language, Music, Dream and Pun, the Probe record shop and, according to some, the magical power of ley lines.

The acid factory that made St Helens fume

Leaks and emissions from a sulphuric acid factory brought constant complaints from local residents. Despite three public inquiries and several prosecutions, the problem continued for years and the council was powerless to stop it.

Pushing the boundaries of education

The City of Liverpool Community College aimed to provide qualifications for people who had left school without a certificate.
It also worked closely with local communities, providing literacy and numeracy classses for adults with poor basic skills. Later, though, the word “community” was dropped from its name.

Reclaim the Night

Women’s campaign against male violence

Trouble in toytown

When the Meccano factory suddenly closed down in 1979, workers fought back by occupying the premises.

How the Campaign for Homosexual Equality brought gay Liverpool out of the shadows

Despite relaxation of the law against homosexuality in 1967, gay people faced a continuing struggle for social acceptance during the 1970s.

The ghost cinemas of Liverpool

With the closure of cinemas Liverpool didn’t just lose buildings. It lost communal dreaming. Cinemas were places where you sat alongside strangers and felt the same fear, laughter, romance, and hope. In a city shaped by migration, war, poverty, and labour, cinemas offered shared narratives that crossed boundaries.

Creating jobs for the jobless

The Job Creation Programme was one of several government initiatives in the 1970s aimed at reducing unemployment, especially among school leavers. Local authorities, businesses and voluntary organisations were all urged to sponsor employment projects, with the government covering wages and other costs from a £75m fund. But what did it achieve?

The privatisation of intelligence gathering

In the political and industrial turmoil of the 1970s, left-wing militants  –  especially among the trade unions  –  were treated as a threat to national security. Monitoring their activity was a task officially assigned to the police Special Branch but the police faced competition in the form of unofficial intelligence networks run by shadowy right-wing organisations. This article looks at the controversy generated by two of them: the Economic League and the Unison Committee for Action.

Rehousing Liverpool (1): From slum clearance to rehabilitation

Slum clearance in the 1960s and 1970s separated people from friends and neighbours they had known for years. Tens of thousands were “decanted” to new estates on the edges of Liverpool. But demolition and displacement weren’t the only options and in Toxteth the Shelter Neighbourhood Action Project initiated a new approach.

Rehousing Liverpool (2): Grassroots initiatives

Housing cooperatives began with the idealistic goal of giving residents control over their own homes. They were voluntary organisations that focused on rehabilitating run-down terraces (and, later, building new estates) with the aid of loans and government grants. Decision-making was in the hands of co-op members rather than the council or private landlords, but the members often had no previous experience working with architects and other professionals – which led to them making some surprising choices.

Rehousing Liverpool (3): Liberal compromises

The Liberals took charge of Liverpool City Council in 1973, though without an overall majority. They abandoned the construction of new council homes in favour of new-build co-ops. Thus what had started out as a radical and marginal movement for residents’ control was watered down as the new mainstream. However, the initial success of these co-ops created a demand for more that was impossible to meet because of government spending restrictions.

Rehousing Liverpool (4): Militant and ‘bourgeois’ housing

For several years in the 1980s Liverpool city council was dominated by members of Labour’s Militant Tendency which promised to build a thousand new council homes every year. Elsewhere in the country, municipal housebuilding was almost at a standstill and the cost of Liverpool’s ambitious plans brought a confrontation with the Thatcher government.

Militant also had ideological objections to housing co-ops which it saw as a backdoor form of privatisation benefiting the bourgeoisie rather than the working class.

Fun in the dismal days of Thatcherism: the story of ‘The End’ magazine

‘The End’ magazine was produced by the young and read by the young. It talked mainly about football, music, beer and made jokes about life without a job. The End had plenty of attitude and was often outrageous. It published witty poems that didn’t always scan and letters from readers who it then insulted in print. But that didn’t matter because it gave people a laugh – and built up a cult following.

Hounded out of town: the caravan dwellers with nowhere to stay

In the 1970s gypsies and other itinerant caravan dwellers faced constant battles with the authorities due to a lack of places where they could legally camp. After eviction from one patch of waste land they would move to another, where the process to evict them would begin again.

Neighbouring local authorities engaged in a sort of ping-pong game, batting the problem of unwelcome caravans back and forth across each other’s administrative boundaries.

A drink in the most dangerous pub … and a riotous night in Kirkby

The Eagle & Child pub in Huyton had a city-wide reputation as a clearing-house for stolen goods. Fights broke out almost every night and police officers who went to take a look would be pelted with eggs and beer. Former Post & Echo journalist John Toker recalls a visit.

Photographing football – with rollickings from Bill Shankly

Stephen Shakeshaft spent four decades chronicling life on Merseyside as a photographer and later as picture editor of the Daily Post & Echo. He describes his experiences photographing football during the Shankly era – and some strange encounters with the boss himself.

Queer-bashed in James Street: the story of a Scout leader who vanished

John Gick disappeared in 1969 during a weekend visit to Liverpool from the Isle of Man. Despite extensive searches and enquiries, the police found no trace of him, alive or dead. The reason for his disappearance is still unknown but delving into the mystery opens a window on the secretive lives of men who struggled with their sexuality in the 1960s and 1970s.

Policing Liverpool: the road to the riots

When Bert Balmer took over as Acting Chief Constable of Liverpool in 1964, tackling high levels of crime in the city centre was his top priority. Determined to take drastic action, he created a special task force with a glamorous-sounding name that was sure to cause a stir in the media and  –  he hoped  –  strike fear into would-be lawbreakers. He called it the Commando Squad.

What no one foresaw was that the battle against street crime initiated by Balmer would lead over time to a breakdown in police-community relations and ultimately to the riots of 1981.

Upping the rent: a landlord’s tricks of the trade

How private landlords drove out tenants whose rents were frozen by law and replaced them with new tenants at higher rents … and how they evaded the Rent Act by pretending tenants were “buyers” or simply “users” of the property.

A pioneer in the struggle for racial justice

The name is Bond … Comrade Bond

In 1984 Sampson Bond, a 26-year-old Londoner, became head of Liverpool city council’s new Race Relations Unit following a rigged selection process. Bond was the least qualified of six applicants for the post but he got the job because his views on race relations matched those of Militant, the Trotskyist group which dominated the city council at the time and believed racial problems would be solved by the defeat of capitalism. His appointment infuriated black and anti-racism groups in the city. They refused to cooperate with him and demanded his dismissal.

The bleak council estate of Netherley was nicknamed Alcatraz because people living there often felt like prisoners. In 1976, though, a group of women took the first step towards building a sense of community – and organised a carnival. Maria O’Reilly describes how they did it and what it achieved.

Colonialism in the classroom: books for children in the 1970s

Amid concern that Liverpool’s schools were not preparing youngsters for life in a multi-racial society, the Community Relations Council carried out a study of racist attitudes in books written for children.

The NHS watchdogs that were allowed to bark but not bite

In 1974 the government established Community Health Councils throughout the country to monitor NHS performance and represent the views of patients and the public. In Liverpool, Sylvia Hikins chaired one of them for nine years, but her hopes of improving health services were constantly battered by spending cuts and closures.

Scotland Road Free School: a devastating report from government inspectors
A highly confidential report by education inspectors in 1973 gave a blistering account of the Free School in its death throes, Liverpool People’s History has discovered.

News from Nowhere: the story of a radical bookshop 
An insider’s view of the shop’s history – by Mandy Vere who worked there for 45 years.

The early years of Women’s Liberation
How the movement evolved on Merseyside in the 1970s and 1980s.

The Bridewell and the Boys from the Blackstuff
Much of Alan Bleasdale’s acclaimed TV drama was filmed at a former police station on Prescot Street.

Police, drugs and ‘agriculture’ in Toxteth
In 1971 there were two notable court cases where black men accused of possessing cannabis were acquitted after claiming police had planted it.

The Liverpool Scene – and beyond
In the 1970s and 1980s Merseyside poets dared to be popular – challenging the idea poems can’t be ʽgood’ unless they are elitist.

International Garden Festival: a treat for ʽcomfortable Britain’
The Garden Festival in 1984 attracted more than three million visitors and helped to regenerate Liverpool. But what benefit did the visitors get from it?

Arthur Dooley, sculptor
The former shipyard welder who turned scrap metal into art.

Merseyside Unity Theatre
Drama and agitprop in the 1970s: an account by one of the theatre’s founders

From word games to Dial-a-Poem
How the Windows Project spread new forms of creativity among children and adults.

Concrete is beautiful: the Shankland master-plan
Graeme Shankland was a planner hired by the council. His vision for Liverpool was to tear down much of the centre and replace it with “robust and manly” new buildings encompassed by an inner motorway on stilts. His plan has since been described as “notorious” and “a nightmare”, and fortunately most of it was eventually abandoned.

The Civic Centre fiasco
In the 1960s Liverpool council embarked on a plan to bring all corporation offices under one roof in a massive city-centre building to be known as the Civic Centre. They spent years buying up properties that stood on the site but the new building became unaffordable and a public inquiry condemned its design as “oppressive” and “overpowering”.

Filming the community: Old Swan festival, 1976
Old Swan was a rather drab part of Liverpool but for a few days in 1976 it became an extraordinary place where residents held a community festival described as “an explosion of colour and noise”. In the midst of that, though, it wasn’t always clear where reality ended and the entertainment began — which in a way added to the fun.

Radio Free Liverpool
On Merseyside in the 1970s clandestine broadcasters played a cat-and-mouse game with the authorities who were seeking to confiscate their transmitters.

‘Seducing’ soldiers
Activists campaigning against Britain’s military presence in Northern Ireland faced surveillance and prosecution during the 1970s.

Liberty Hall
A club “for people who are interested in politics but don’t wish to belong to a political party”.

The battle to save Fisher Bendix
The Fisher Bendix factory in Kirkby had been built with government help to ease unemployment in the area. It wasn’t a success and in 1972 when the owners tried to shut it down workers occupied the factory in an effort to save their jobs. Three years later they began running it themselves.

Trade unions? No thanks! We’re Marks & Spencer
M&S, in its own estimation, was such a good employer that unions were unnecessary. In theory, staff were free to join one if they wished, but the company had ways of making sure that unions didn’t gain a foothold.

Where women ‘never had time to get bored’
Litttlewoods football pools once provided jobs for thousands of Liverpool women. Former employees describe what it was like to work there.

Revolting students: the Liverpool University sit-in, 1970
Students accused the university of ignoring its responsibilities by trying to isolate itself from the social and political consequences of its policy decisions. They occupied the university’s Senate House building for ten days and nights. One participant was expelled and nine others were suspended.

Democracy in the classroom: Scotland Road Free School
Come to school when you want and do what you like. An experiment in classroom democracy that didn’t work out.

GET INVOLVED
Since this is a “people’s history” website, it’s intended as a collaborative effort. Click here to find out the various ways you can take part.