John Gick disappeared in 1969 during a weekend visit to Liverpool from the Isle of Man. Despite extensive searches and enquiries, the police found no trace of him, alive or dead. The reason for his disappearance is still unknown but delving into the mystery opens a window on the secretive lives of men who struggled with their sexuality in the 1960s and 1970s.

One Saturday in 1969 a group of Scouts travelled from the Isle of Man to see Birkenhead Scouts perform their annual Gang Show. Accompanying the twelve boys was the organiser of the visit: John Gick, a senior figure in the island’s Scout movement who held the title of Commissioner for Cubs.
The ferry docked in Liverpool around 1pm and the group made their way to Scout headquarters in Birkenhead.
The boys had been looking forward to some sightseeing in Liverpool before the evening show but Gick surprised them by saying he had to “return a book” and would be going into the city alone. Promising to be back in time for the show, he left them in the Scout HQ with one of the older boys in charge.
That was the last that any of the Scouts saw of Commissioner Gick. As the start time for the show approached the boys became anxious — not least because he had gone off with their tickets — and eventually the police were called.
Gick’s mini-van, which he had brought with him on the ferry, was quickly found near the Pier Head — unlocked and with blood on the front passenger seat. There were also bloodstained handkerchiefs, tissues and a scarf in the door pocket.
Despite extensive searches and enquiries in the weeks and months that followed, the police found no trace of Gick, alive or dead: he had completely vanished. In the words of the Liverpool Echo, he was “the man who stepped into nowhere”.
Mugged in a public lavatory
Gick’s last confirmed location, around 5pm on the day he vanished, was in James Street, Liverpool, where he had been beaten and robbed on the steps of a public lavatory. Neither Gick nor anyone else had reported it to the police and the crime only came to light a few weeks later when a teenager was found in possession of Gick’s Post Office savings book. Three youths subsequently confessed to mugging him.
This brought a new dimension to the story, because the lavatory in question was a popular spot for men to go “cottaging” and was known in gay circles as the “Garden of Allah” — an obscure reference to verses in the Qur’an that describe Heaven as a garden where the faithful are plied with refreshments by beautiful young men.
The police, of course, knew perfectly well what sort of refreshments were on offer in the James Street “garden” but they didn’t talk about it in public. The local press undoubtedly knew too but didn’t mention it directly. They did, however, repeatedly note that Gick, in addition to being a Scout leader, was a “bachelor”.
Life in the closet
In the late 1960s it was rare for gay men to be “out and proud” about their sexuality: attitudes at the time made them fearful of the consequences. But there were degrees of “outness”. While some hid their sexuality completely, others tried to be discreet, some were “out” among like-minded friends and a few brave souls took delight in shocking people with their scandalous behaviour.
Opting to be in the closet gave no guarantee of staying there, however. Aside from the possibility of arrest, there was always a chance of being outed by accident — for example being spotted going into a gay bar.
First-hand accounts of gay life at the time can be found in a ninety-minute documentary — Pink: Past and Present — which traces the emergence of Merseyside’s LGBT community and its struggles for acceptance through the recollections of people who experienced it. The film begins with reminiscences of cottaging and its prevalence in the late 1960s and early 1970s. One of the men interviewed says it was “the only way you could meet gay people”, while another describes it as “the main scene” for most gay men.
In the absence of dating websites and apps like Grindr, public lavatories were the easiest place to find men looking for sex with other men, and for those who needed secrecy the anonymity was a bonus: no names, no chat-up — just a brief sexual encounter with someone they might never meet again. The James Street lavatory was one of the busiest. Close to the main bus station and the Mersey ferries at the Pier Head, it attracted a lot of passing trade.
Many of the “cottages” were no doubt squalid places but others, in the words of one man who patronised them, were “like ballrooms” — fine examples of antique plumbing and porcelain. The better-known ones had nicknames which gay men used in conversation in case someone overheard them. “Head Office” was code for Lime Street station — an “excellent” place according to one former user — while the “Wheel of Fortune” referred to a circular underground lavatory which was opposite the Playhouse theatre and frequented by actors.

Some of the lavatories were “like ballrooms”
There was a risk of being caught, though, and the film includes one account from a man who had been arrested when police raided a “cottage” in Victoria Street and bundled everyone into a van:
“This fella sitting next to me [in the police van] said ‘I’m actually married … I don’t know what my wife’s gonna say’, and I said ‘Well, you’ll have to come clean now, won’t you’.”
Besides the risk of arrest, men who went cottaging or cruising for sex were especially vulnerable to “queer-bashing” — muggings of the kind that befell John Gick. They were often reluctant to go to the police, either because the circumstances were embarrassing or because they didn’t expect the police to be sympathetic – and that increased the perpetrators’ chances of getting away with it.
While there’s no confirmation that Gick was illegally cottaging in James Street , the fact that he didn’t report the mugging suggests he hadn’t just gone there for a pee. The nature of his sexuality is far from clear, though. He had no obvious interest in women but whether he considered himself “gay” is another matter. Accounts of his time with the Manx Scouts do point to a man grappling with desires that society regarded as shameful but there’s no evidence that this translated into sexual acts involving Scouts.
A boy on the Isle of Man
Two years after Gick’s disappearance the body of a man was found in Staffordshire, buried on a secluded island on the River Trent. It was a gruesome discovery that attracted much publicity at the time: the man had been buried in a kneeling position with his wrists and ankles tied, and was naked apart from his socks and a gold wedding ring on his right hand.
The body has never been identified and in 2021 a man named Ken Davies decided to see if he could solve the mystery. He began working through a list of disappeared people in the hope of finding one that could be linked with the body and reported his progress in a series of podcasts which drew other would-be detectives into the project.
Not surprisingly, Gick’s name was on the checklist and while Davies’ investigation failed to solve the mystery of his disappearance, it did reveal new information about his life on the Isle of Man.
One of the people Davies spoke to was “Jim” (not his real name), a former Scout who said Gick had shown a particular interest in him from the age of ten or eleven and would give him a lift home after Scout meetings — a privilege not accorded to other boys.
When Jim was fifteen Gick took him to a Gang Show in London, with permission from the boy’s parents. The trip included an overnight stay where the pair shared a hotel bedroom, though nothing inappropriate happened: it appears to have been a platonic relationship.
When Jim left school after his O-Levels, Gick fixed him up at an insurance firm in Douglas, working as a clerk. He arranged it through a friend who worked there: Ken Dale, a man whose campness was likened to that of the actor John Inman.
Sometime later — about six months before his disappearance — Gick invited Jim to dinner with himself and Dale. They drove to a restaurant in the north of the island which was well away from Douglas — apparently to reduce the chances of being spotted. As with the earlier trip to London, there were no sexual advances but as the evening wore on Dale’s mannerisms became more and more effeminate — which made Jim uncomfortable.
Back in the insurance office next day, Jim told colleagues about the dinner — which resulted in Dale being summarily dismissed for inappropriate behaviour. Shortly afterwards, Jim left the island to take up a job with the Pilkington glass firm in St Helens.
That appeared to have severed the relationship but Gick hadn’t forgotten about Jim. Before setting off for Liverpool with the Scout group, he had sent a letter to Jim which arrived on February 1 — the day of Gick’s disappearance. The contents of the letter were never disclosed but in view of the timing it’s likely Gick was seeking to meet him.

Liverpool Echo, 5 February 1969, p1
At that stage Jim was staying at the YMCA in St Helens on work days and spending weekends with his sister in Crosby. The letter appears to have arrived at his sister’s home, because that is where the police turned up four days later. Jim’s sister told them he was at work in St Helens and they hurried off to Pilkington’s to interview him about Gick. They left seven hours later and Jim never heard from them again.
Visits to Liverpool
Manx people who knew Gick described him as quiet, diligent, hardworking and unassuming. Aside from the Scouting he had spent more than 20 years as an accounts clerk at the Isle of Man Steamship Company which ran ferries between the island and Liverpool. It was a dull job but it came with a perk: employees could travel on the ferries free of charge.
The police were surprised to find how often Gick had made use of that facility for trips to Liverpool and it made them wonder what he had been doing there. They were reported to be checking with unspecified “clubs” and they also showed interest in a couple of hotels.
The purpose of Gick’s visits is unknown but, for a man struggling with his sexuality on the Isle of Man, Liverpool — with a few gay-orientated bars and an embryonic gay community — was clearly a more attractive place to be. The Isle of Man, in contrast, had a population of only 55,000 — too small to sustain much of a gay community — and it still clung to very traditional ideas about sex.
Another significant factor was the 1967 Sexual Offences Act which relaxed the law on homosexuality. Cottaging remained illegal but “private homosexual acts between men aged over 21” were no longer a crime. The Isle of Man is partly self-governing, however, and when the law changed in mainland Britain the Manx parliament held out against it. All kinds of gay sex remained illegal on the island until 1992.

Liverpool Daily Post, 7 February 1969, p5
The mystery continues
There are several hypotheses regarding Gick’s fate. The story told at the trial of his teenage muggers was that they had punched him in the face, knocking him down, and then made off with his savings book, leaving him lying on the lavatory steps.
His injuries don’t appear to have been life-threatening, though. The supposition, based on the blood found in Gick’s mini-van, is that he returned to the vehicle after the attack and left again sometime later, without locking it.
Assuming he survived the mugging, could he have been murdered by someone else? To have been mugged and then murdered in a separate attack later on the same day would be an extraordinary misfortune. Conceivably it could have happened but there’s no supporting evidence – most crucially in the form of a dead body.
Another possibility is suicide. It’s not difficult to visualise Gick in a state of shock after the mugging, wiping blood from his face in the mini-van and desperately wondering what to do next. He clearly had no desire to tell the police, but what on earth was he to tell the Scouts anxiously awaiting him in Birkenhead? If the whole truth about his mugging ever got back to the Isle of Man his reputation would be ruined and his Scouting activities would be finished. To make matters worse, his attempt to renew contact with Jim, the young man he had doted on since childhood, appeared to have failed.
In that situation Gick could have felt his whole world was falling apart, so perhaps in a moment of panic he decided to end his troubles and (since he was at the Pier Head) threw himself into the Mersey. Again, though, the problem is a lack of supporting evidence. The bodies of people who drown in the river almost always turn up eventually, but it’s possible Gick was an exception.
The remaining hypothesis – a potentially happier one – is that he survived, having gone into hiding and started a new life elsewhere. That theory gained some support when an employee of the ferry company later claimed to have spotted him, though the police were sceptical: false reports of sightings were not uncommon in such cases. There were also doubts about Gick’s ability to make a fresh start without access to money, since his Post Office savings book had been stolen in the mugging.
The long and short of it is that we can only guess at his fate and will probably never know what actually happened to him.
FURTHER INFORMATION
BACKGROUND
Pink Past and Present
An award-winning feature length documentary film which explores the rich, vibrant and often turbulent history of Liverpool’s lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community from the 1950s onwards. It was premiered at Homotopia and screened at FACT as part of Liverpool Pride 2012.
Queer Places
Website taking a historical look at Liverpool’s gay meeting places.
The Mysterious Case of Fred the Head
Podcasts by Ken Davies. Gick’s case is discussed in the following episodes:
Episode 41 – The Man who Stepped into Nowhere
Episode 43 – The Scout’s Story
Episode 45 – The Connection
Episode 47 – Man to Man
Episode 49 – Scouting for Boys
PRESS REPORTS ON THE DISAPPEARANCE OF JOHN GICK
Riddle of the missing scouter
Liverpool Echo, 4 February 1969, p1
Scouts may join hunt for missing leader
Liverpool Echo, 5 February 1969, p1
Riddle remains: why did scout man vanish?
Liverpool Daily Post, 7 February 1969, p5
Scoutmaster: Police step up search
Liverpool Echo, 3 March 1969, p1
Search for scouter widens
Liverpool Daily Post, 19 March 1969, p1
Scouter riddle remains unsolved
Liverpool Daily Post (Welsh edition), 24 April 1969, p13
Court story of attack on scout leader
Isle of Man Times, 25 April 1969, p7
Missing scoutmaster seen at Birkenhead docks – report
Liverpool Echo, 7 May 1969, p1
CID told: I’ve seen missing scouter
Liverpool Daily Post, 8 May 1969, p1
The man who stepped into nowhere
Liverpool Echo, 19 June 1969, p3
Scoutmaster left no tracks
Liverpool Echo, 2 September 1969, p6
Still no trace of the missing scoutmaster
Liverpool Daily Post, 17 November 1969, p7
Scoutmaster Gick: police have hunted for a year and the trail is going cold
Liverpool Daily Post, 29 January 1970, p5



















0 Comments